Dr.Vakuum
Alle Anwendungen

Vacuum for sugar mill evaporators and vacuum pans

7 Min. Lesezeit

Thailand crushes around a hundred million tonnes of cane a season, and every tonne of it passes through a vacuum station twice: once in the multiple-effect evaporators that take clarified juice from 15 to 65 °Brix, and once in the vacuum pans where the syrup is boiled to grain. The vacuum is what lets water boil at 55–65 °C instead of 100 — which is the difference between white sugar and caramel.

This note is about how that vacuum is made, what the pump actually has to remove (far less than people assume), and how to size and run a liquid ring pump through a crushing season when the cooling water is 32 °C.

1. Where the vacuum comes from

A sugar evaporator or pan is boiling. The vapour it produces — tonnes per hour — does not go to a vacuum pump. It goes to a condenser, where injection water (or a surface condenser) turns it back into liquid at a fraction of its vapour volume. The condensation is what creates the vacuum. The pump's job is to remove the gas that cannot be condensed: the non-condensables.

Non-condensables in a sugar station come from:

  • Air dissolved in the juice, released as it boils. Roughly 20–30 litres of air per tonne of juice at atmospheric conditions.
  • Air in the injection water of a barometric condenser — typically the largest contributor, 15–25 L of air per m³ of injection water.
  • Air in-leakage through the vessel joints, sight glasses, probe glands and the many kilometres of pipe in an old factory.
  • Gases from the sugar itself — small amounts of CO₂ and volatile organics from the decomposition of reducing sugars.

A typical last-effect evaporator body or pan runs at 80–150 mbar absolute (about 630–680 mmHg vacuum). The vapour temperature at 100 mbar is 46 °C. The pump therefore works at the condenser's operating pressure, pulling a mixture of air and water vapour saturated at the condenser outlet temperature.

2. Sizing the non-condensable load

The design method in the sugar industry is empirical, and the coefficients are known. For a barometric (direct-contact) condenser:

Q_air (kg/h) ≈ 0.025 × W_inj + 0.03 × W_juice + leakage

where W_inj is injection water in m³/h and W_juice is juice or syrup boiled in t/h. For a pan station boiling 40 t/h of massecuite with 800 m³/h of injection water across the condensers:

Q_air ≈ 0.025 × 800 + 0.03 × 40 + 15 (leakage) ≈ 36 kg/h of air

Air at 36 kg/h is about 30 Nm³/h. But the pump does not see air at normal conditions. It sees air saturated with water vapour at the condenser tail temperature and pressure. At 100 mbar and a tail temperature of 40 °C (vapour pressure 74 mbar), the vapour accounts for 74 % of the gas volume. The actual volume to pump is

V = 30 Nm³/h × (1013 / 100) × (313 / 273) × [100 / (100 − 74)] ≈ 1,340 m³/h

That factor of 45 between the normal-condition air flow and the actual inlet volume is the whole point of this section. Cool the condenser tail and you shrink the pump. The same 30 Nm³/h at a tail temperature of 30 °C (vapour pressure 42 mbar) is 870 m³/h — a third smaller.

Why does the seal water temperature matter so much?

A liquid ring pump compresses gas with a ring of water, and the water evaporates into the gas. The lowest pressure the pump can reach is set by the vapour pressure of the seal water: at 32 °C that is 48 mbar, so the pump's effective ultimate is around 60 mbar, and at 100 mbar it is already running at only 40 % of its catalogue speed. The same pump with 20 °C seal water reaches 33 mbar and keeps most of its capacity. In a Thai April, river or cooling-tower water is 30–34 °C, which is exactly why pumps sized for the European catalogue curve disappoint in Kanchanaburi. Size on the hot-water curve, or install a small closed-loop chiller for the seal water — a few kilowatts of cooling recovers a great deal of pumping speed.

3. Liquid ring versus steam ejectors versus hybrids

Most Thai mills were built with multi-stage steam-jet ejectors drawing the non-condensables. Ejectors have no moving parts and tolerate anything, but they consume motive steam continuously — typically 2–4 kg of steam per kg of air removed, through the whole season. In a mill that sells bagasse power to the grid, that steam is money.

Steam ejector Liquid ring pump Hybrid (ejector + liquid ring)
Energy 2–4 kg steam / kg air 0.5–0.9 kWh / kg air Between the two
Lowest practical pressure 30 mbar (two-stage) 60–100 mbar (hot seal water) 30–50 mbar
Tolerance to carry-over Excellent Good — liquid slugs pass Good
Maintenance Nozzle erosion, annual Bearings, seals; 2–3 seasons Both
Turndown Poor — fixed geometry Good with VSD Good

The usual engineering answer for a pan station at 80–150 mbar is a liquid ring pump alone, sized on the hot-water curve. For an evaporator last effect pulled down to 50–60 mbar for a reason, a hybrid — one steam ejector stage discharging into a liquid ring pump — cuts the ejector's steam by 60–70 % while keeping the low pressure.

4. Running through the season

Four practices separate a pump that lasts ten seasons from one that is rebuilt every off-crop:

  1. Seal water quality. Mill water carries fibre and lime. A simple cyclone or 500 µm strainer on the seal water supply, and a recirculation tank with a heat exchanger, stop the abrasive wear that opens the clearances and loses capacity season by season.
  2. Partial recirculation. Fresh seal water once-through is wasteful; total recirculation runs hot. Recirculate with 20–30 % make-up and a plate heat exchanger against cooling tower water.
  3. Materials. Condensate from sugar vapour is slightly acidic (pH 5–6, from organic acids). Stainless steel impellers and port plates are the right default; cast iron pumps lose metal every season.
  4. Carry-over protection. When a pan "boils over" the condenser sends sugar-laden water towards the pump. A knock-out pot with a level switch ahead of the pump inlet turns a rebuild into a wash-down.

5. A worked station

A 12,000 tcd (tonnes cane per day) mill, pan station: six pans, condensers at 100 mbar, injection water 1,100 m³/h at a tail temperature of 38 °C, leakage estimated at 25 kg/h for an older plant.

  • Air load: 0.025 × 1,100 + 0.03 × 55 + 25 ≈ 54 kg/h ≈ 45 Nm³/h
  • Vapour pressure at 38 °C: 66 mbar → vapour fraction 66 %
  • Inlet volume at 100 mbar, 38 °C: 45 × 10.1 × 1.14 × (100/34) ≈ 1,520 m³/h
  • Seal water at 32 °C → use the hot-water curve: a pump rated 2,600 m³/h nominal delivers roughly 1,500–1,700 m³/h at 100 mbar

That points to one LS520-400 (2,600 m³/h nominal, 55 kW) — or, for redundancy through a 150-day season, two LS410-320 at 1,400 m³/h each, one running on the evaporators and one on the pans, with a cross-over header so either can carry the other during maintenance. A VSD on each drops power at the start of the week when the pans are clean and the leakage is low.

Recommended Dr.Vakuum machines

Liquid ring, single-stage (LS Series) — the backbone of a sugar vacuum station: large capacities at 80–150 mbar, tolerant of saturated vapour and the occasional slug of condensate.

Model Nominal capacity, 50 Hz Motor Suits
LS275-220 650 m³/h 15 kW Single pan or small refinery station
LS410-320 1,400 m³/h 37 kW Pan station, 6,000–8,000 tcd
LS520-400 2,600 m³/h 55 kW Pan or evaporator station, 10,000–14,000 tcd
LS780-1100 — — Largest stations; sized per enquiry

Liquid ring, two-stage (LT Series) — where an effect or a pan is pulled below 60 mbar and the seal water is warm, the second stage holds capacity where a single stage falls away: LT380-320, LT520-400.

Roots booster (MB Series) — in front of a liquid ring pump for a hybrid that reaches 30–40 mbar without steam: MB1200 ahead of an LT.

Season planning. Send us your injection water flow, condenser pressure and tail temperature, and your cooling water temperature in April. We size on the hot-water curve and show the steam saving against your ejectors. Talk to an engineer.