Dr.Vakuum
การประยุกต์ใช้งานทั้งหมด

Vacuum pump or blower? Choosing by flow and depth, and the expensive mistake

อ่าน 7 นาที

The most common sizing mistake we see is not a pump that is too small. It is a pump where a blower belonged, or the reverse. A rotary vane pump bought for a hold-down table runs at a fraction of its capability and still cannot hold the panel; a side channel blower bought for a packaging machine never gets below 600 mbar. Both were "vacuum equipment"; neither was the right kind.

The way to avoid it is to place the duty on a map with two axes — flow and depth — before looking at any catalogue.

1. The two axes

Depth is how far below atmosphere the process needs to be. Blowers work in the first few hundred millibar; pumps go the rest of the way. The boundary is physical: a blower moves gas without sealing it in a closed chamber, so it cannot generate a large pressure ratio.

Flow is how much gas must be moved per unit time at that depth. Blowers are inherently high-flow machines; a pump of the same motor power moves less gas but moves it against a much larger pressure difference.

Depth below atmosphere Absolute pressure Machines that live here
0 – 100 mbar 1,013 – 900 mbar Centrifugal blowers (CB), small side channel
100 – 400 mbar 900 – 600 mbar Side channel (1SC, 2SC), Roots vacuum (RBV)
400 – 600 mbar 600 – 400 mbar Two-stage side channel, Roots vacuum, dry claw (CL)
600 – 900 mbar 400 – 100 mbar Dry claw, dry vane (DRV), liquid ring
900 – 1,000 mbar 100 – 10 mbar Liquid ring (LM/LT), oil-sealed vane (V), dry screw (DSI)
below 10 mbar abs 10 – 10⁻³ mbar Oil-sealed vane, dry screw, Roots booster (MB)
high vacuum < 10⁻³ mbar Turbomolecular (T), cryopump (CR)

Why can't a blower just run longer to go deeper?

Because a blower's depth is set by its geometry and speed, not by how long it runs. A side channel blower generates pressure by flinging gas outward in a ring of impeller blades; each pass adds a fixed increment of pressure, and the increment does not grow with time. Run it against a closed inlet and it reaches its maximum differential — 200–400 mbar for a single stage — and sits there, heating up. A positive-displacement pump, by contrast, traps a volume and expels it every revolution, so the pressure keeps falling until leakage or vapour pressure balances it. That is the difference between a blower and a pump, and no amount of running time changes it.

2. Reading the units

Blower and pump catalogues use different units because they come from different trades, and the conversions are where quotations go wrong.

Unit Who uses it Equals
mbar (absolute) Vacuum pump datasheets 1 mbar = 100 Pa = 0.1 kPa
mbar (vacuum / differential) Side channel blowers depth below 1,013 mbar atmospheric
kPa Centrifugal and Roots blowers 1 kPa = 10 mbar
mmAq / mmH₂O Roots blowers (Japanese tradition) 1,000 mmAq = 9.8 kPa = 98 mbar
inHg (vacuum) US dry vane / claw 1 inHg = 33.9 mbar; 27 inHg vac ≈ 98 mbar abs
mmHg / Torr Older process plant 1 mmHg = 1.333 mbar; 735 mmHg vac ≈ 33 mbar abs

Two traps. First, "−5,000 mmAq" on a Roots vacuum blower is a differential of 49 kPa — about 490 mbar below atmosphere, i.e. 520 mbar absolute. Second, "0.5 mbar" on a vane pump is absolute: 1,012.5 mbar below atmosphere. The two machines are not comparable on the same scale, which is the whole point of the map.

3. Where side channel ends and claw begins

The practical boundary between blower and pump territory is 300–450 mbar below atmosphere, and it is worth knowing what happens to each machine there.

A single-stage side channel blower like the 1SC429 delivers 216 m³/h at open inlet and holds a maximum of about 180–220 mbar differential. A two-stage like the 2SC6375 reaches 420–580 mbar, but at that depth it is moving a fraction of its free-air flow and drawing its full 7.5 kW to do it. Side channel blowers are efficient where the curve is flat — up to about 60 % of their maximum differential — and wasteful beyond it.

A dry claw pump like the CL150 moves 150 m³/h at open inlet and keeps most of that down to 500–600 mbar below atmosphere, with an ultimate of 150 mbar absolute. Below 300 mbar differential it is doing what a blower could do with less power; above 400 mbar it is doing what no blower can.

So: duty at 100–300 mbar differential, high flow → blower. Duty at 400 mbar and deeper → pump. Between 300 and 400 mbar, the choice is made by flow (large flow favours a two-stage blower or a Roots vacuum blower) and by what is in the gas (claw tolerates dust and some liquid; side channel blowers do not like either).

4. The expensive mistake, costed

A furniture factory buys a 300 m³/h oil-sealed rotary vane pump (7.5 kW) for a CNC hold-down table that leaks about 200 m³/h at 250 mbar differential. The pump's displacement is 300 m³/h, so it "should" cope. In practice:

  • The pump runs flat out at 750 mbar absolute, a pressure where it was never designed to live; its oil mist separator is overloaded by the continuous airflow, and it emits oil mist onto the shop floor.
  • It consumes 7.5 kW continuously.
  • The oil degrades in weeks from the oxygen throughput.

The right machine, a 1SC529 side channel blower, delivers 312 m³/h at open inlet, holds 230 mbar, runs dry, and draws 2.2 kW. Over a 4,000-hour year at 4.5 THB/kWh the difference is (7.5 − 2.2) × 4,000 × 4.5 ≈ 95,000 THB a year in electricity alone, before the oil, the filters and the lacquer defects.

The reverse mistake costs differently. A chamber packaging machine needing 5 mbar fitted with a 2SC blower reaches 500 mbar and stops. There is no partial credit: the pack has 50 % residual air and the product spoils. The blower is simply the wrong tool.

5. The decision table

Find the row that matches the process, then the column that matches the gas.

Duty Depth (below atm) Flow Clean, dry air Dust / fibre Wet / vapour
Pick-and-place, lifting, conveying 100–300 mbar high 1SC RBV with filter —
CNC hold-down, porous 200–350 mbar high 1SC / 2SC 2SC with filter CL
Central cleaning 200–400 mbar high 2SC RBV —
Medical, dental, clinic 450–600 mbar medium CL — CL
Seaming, forming, light holding 500–900 mbar medium DRV CL LM
Drying, degassing, evaporation 900–990 mbar (10–100 abs) medium–high V, DSI DSI LM / LT
Packaging, impregnation 990–1,012 mbar (1–20 abs) medium V DSI V + ballast
Furnaces, coating forevacuum 0.01–1 mbar abs medium–high DV, MB + V DSI + MB —

If the duty is in the first three rows and someone has quoted a pump, or in the last three and someone has quoted a blower, the quotation is wrong before the price is read.

6. Pressure blowers: the other direction

The same map applies to positive pressure. Side channel blowers deliver 200–600 mbar of pressure; Roots blowers (RB Series) deliver up to 78 kPa (8,000 mmAq, about 800 mbar) at very high flows for aeration and pneumatic conveying; centrifugal blowers deliver 1–20 kPa for drying and air knives. Dry vane machines in combined vacuum-pressure form — the DRK Series — supply both suction and blast air from one shaft for printing presses and paper handling, which is the one duty that genuinely needs both.

Recommended Dr.Vakuum machines by position on the map

Position Series Example model Flow, 50 Hz Max depth
Shallow, high flow 1SC side channel 1SC429 216 m³/h 180–220 mbar diff.
Shallow–medium, high flow 2SC side channel 2SC4337 222 m³/h 345–410 mbar diff.
Shallow, very high flow RBV Roots vacuum RBV100 347–801 m³/h 490 mbar diff.
Medium, dry CL claw CL150 150 m³/h 150 mbar abs
Medium, dry, oil-free DRV dry vane DRV40 48 m³/h 90 mbar abs
Medium–deep, wet LM liquid ring LM200-065 105 m³/h 33 mbar abs
Deep V oil-sealed vane V140 132 m³/h 0.5 mbar abs
Deep, dry DSI dry screw DSI300 300 m³/h 0.05 mbar abs

Not sure which side of the line you are on? Tell us the process, the flow if you know it and the pressure you need, in whatever units your drawing uses. We will place it on the map and tell you which machine — and which you should not buy. Talk to an engineer.