Dr.Vakuum
การประยุกต์ใช้งานทั้งหมด

Vacuum pick-and-place, lifting and robotic handling: flow, not depth

อ่าน 7 นาที

A suction cup is the simplest vacuum application there is, and it is sized wrong more often than any other, because the arithmetic that everyone learns — force equals pressure times area — is only half of it. The other half is flow: the cup is never sealed, the workpiece leaks, and the generator must remove air as fast as it arrives or the cup lets go. End-of-arm tooling on palletising robots, vacuum lifters for sheet and panel, and the pick-and-place heads on packaging lines all live by that second half.

1. Holding force and the safety factor

The force available from a cup is the pressure difference across it times its effective area:

F = Δp × A

A 100 mm diameter cup (A = 7,850 mm² = 0.00785 m²) at 400 mbar differential (40,000 Pa) gives 314 N — about 32 kgf. That is the static, vertical, perfectly sealed figure. In practice:

  • Safety factor 2 for horizontal lifting at low acceleration.
  • Safety factor 4 for vertical surfaces (friction, not suction, holds the load; μ ≈ 0.5 for rubber on cardboard) and for robots that accelerate at 1–2 g.
  • Safety factor 6–8 where the surface is wet, oily or dusty.

So that 100 mm cup lifts a 15 kg carton on a palletiser, or 8 kg from a vertical pick, or 5 kg of oily steel sheet. Industrial practice settles at −400 to −600 mbar for non-porous loads and −200 to −400 mbar for porous ones — and the reason porous loads run at lower vacuum is the whole subject of the next section.

Why does a porous carton need more flow but less vacuum?

Because the cup is drawing air through the cardboard continuously. A corrugated case leaks 1–3 m³/h per 100 mm cup at 300 mbar differential, and the leak rises with the differential. Pull harder and you pull more air through the board, not more force onto it: a 600 mbar differential on a corrugated case leaks so fast that most generators cannot hold it, and it crushes the top flap. The design response is more cups at a modest vacuum (200–300 mbar) and a generator with the flow to feed them — which is why palletisers run side channel blowers while sheet-metal lifters run small pumps or ejectors.

2. Estimating the leak

Workpiece Leak per 100 mm cup at 300 mbar Working vacuum
Steel, glass, plastic sheet (smooth, dry) ~0 −600 to −800 mbar
Laminated or coated board, shrink-wrapped tray 0.2–0.5 m³/h −400 to −500 mbar
Corrugated case, closed, taped 1–3 m³/h −250 to −350 mbar
Corrugated case, open flaps, perforated 3–8 m³/h −200 to −300 mbar
Paper sacks, woven PP bags 5–15 m³/h −150 to −250 mbar
Plywood, MDF, veneer 2–6 m³/h −300 to −400 mbar
Textiles, foam 10–30 m³/h −100 to −200 mbar

Add the cup seal leak — a foam-ring or bellows cup on an uneven surface leaks 0.5–2 m³/h of its own — and the pick-up transient: the cup's internal volume plus the hose must be evacuated each cycle. For a gripper with eight 100 mm cups on an open-flap case:

Q ≈ 8 × (5 + 1) = 48 m³/h at 250 mbar, plus 10 % for the hose and valve

A blower delivering 55 m³/h at 250 mbar differential — read from the curve at that point, not at open inlet — holds the gripper. The 1SC229 (84 m³/h free air, 110–130 mbar maximum) will not; the 1SC429 (216 m³/h free air, 180–220 mbar) is marginal at 250 mbar; a 2SC3315 two-stage (156 m³/h free air, 345 mbar maximum) holds comfortably with margin for a torn carton.

3. Generators: ejector, blower or pump

Venturi ejectors run on compressed air and are the right choice for small, non-porous picks on fast robots: no moving parts, mounted at the cup, millisecond response, and the depth (−850 mbar) to grip smooth sheet. Their flow is tiny — 1–5 m³/h — and their compressed-air cost is enormous per m³ of vacuum: an ejector consuming 100 L/min of 6-bar air to produce 2 m³/h of vacuum uses about 0.6 kW, so a palletiser gripper on ejectors can burn 5–10 kW of compressor power to do what a 2.2 kW blower does.

Side channel blowers (1SC and 2SC Series) are the right generator for porous, leaky loads: 50–1,100 m³/h, 150–580 mbar, dry, continuous, and the leak is their design condition. Mount one per robot (on the base, not the arm) or one per line.

Centrifugal blowers (CB Series) serve very porous, very low-vacuum duties — textile handling, paper and foam — where 3–15 kPa (30–150 mbar) is enough and the flow is large: the CB125A moves 32 m³/min (1,900 m³/h) at 2.4 kPa for 2.2 kW.

Dry claw and dry vane pumps (CL, DRV) suit mixed lines where the gripper must handle both sealed and porous loads at −500 mbar or deeper and the leak is moderate; the claw's 150 mbar ultimate means it holds −800 mbar on a sealed load and still delivers most of its flow at −300 mbar on a porous one.

4. Point-of-use or central

A plant with twelve robot cells, each with a blower, has twelve blowers to maintain and twelve exhausts to deal with. A central vacuum system — one or two large blowers or a Roots vacuum blower feeding a ring main at −300 to −400 mbar, with a receiver and a VSD — replaces them. The arguments:

  • Diversity. Not every gripper is lifting at once; a central system sized at 60–70 % of the sum of the peaks is usually enough, and the receiver covers the coincidences.
  • Energy. One RBV125 Roots vacuum blower on a VSD following demand uses less than twelve blowers each running flat out at idle.
  • Noise and heat move to the plant room.
  • Against: a central system is a single point of failure (hence duplex), the ring main loses 20–50 mbar, and a torn bag on one cell pulls the whole main down for a second. Zone valves and a receiver per zone answer most of that.

The usual line: ejectors on the fast case-packer heads, one side channel blower per palletising robot, and a central system only when there are more than six or eight robots on one floor.

5. Vacuum lifters for sheet, panel and sacks

Manual vacuum lifters — the hoist-mounted beam with four to eight cups that lets one operator move a 300 kg sheet or a 50 kg sack — have the same physics with a different safety emphasis: the load is above people. EN 13155 requires the lifter to hold the load for at least five minutes after a power failure, so lifters carry a vacuum reservoir, a non-return valve and an audible low-vacuum alarm, and the generator is sized to recover the reservoir between lifts rather than to hold a leak. Sheet lifters use a small dry vane or claw pump (−600 to −800 mbar, 10–50 m³/h); sack and panel lifters use a side channel blower (−250 to −400 mbar, 100–300 m³/h), and the blower runs continuously because the load leaks continuously.

6. Installation points

  • Filter at the gripper, not only at the blower: cardboard dust and corn-starch from bag seams reach the impeller otherwise. Inline filter rated 5–10 µm, with a visible differential indicator.
  • Hose bore. A 10 m run of 25 mm hose at 50 m³/h loses about 30 mbar; go to 32 or 40 mm on anything above 40 m³/h.
  • Vacuum switch at the cup manifold, set 50 mbar below working vacuum, interlocked to the robot's "part present" logic.
  • Blow-off: a short pulse of compressed air through the cup releases a lightweight load the vacuum would otherwise hold for a moment; it is a few litres per cycle.
  • Relief valve on the blower inlet: a side channel blower against a blocked line overheats; a relief set 50 mbar above working vacuum protects it.

Recommended Dr.Vakuum machines

Single-stage side channel (1SC Series) — one per robot or line, porous loads at 150–220 mbar:

Model Free air, 50 Hz Max vacuum Suits
1SC229 84 m³/h 110–130 mbar Small case picks, trays
1SC429 216 m³/h 180–220 mbar One palletising robot, closed cases
1SC529 312 m³/h 220–230 mbar One robot, open or perforated cases
1SC729 552 m³/h ~300 mbar Two robots, or sacks

Two-stage side channel (2SC Series) — deeper vacuum for mixed loads and bags: 2SC3315 (156 m³/h, 345 mbar), 2SC4337 (222 m³/h, 345–410 mbar), 2SC6375 (312 m³/h, 420–580 mbar).

Roots vacuum blowers (RBV Series) — central systems: RBV080, RBV125.

Dry claw (CL Series) — mixed sealed/porous grippers and sheet lifters: CL80, CL150.

For the hold-down tables that use the same physics with a fixed workpiece, see Sizing vacuum hold-down for CNC routers.

Gripper check. Tell us the load, the surface, the number and size of cups and the cycle rate, and we will size the generator from the leak rather than the force. Talk to an engineer.