Sizing vacuum hold-down for CNC routers
Vacuum hold-down is the only workholding method that leaves all five sides of a panel accessible to the cutter. It is also the one most often sized by guesswork — a pump is chosen on its ultimate vacuum, the table never pulls down, and the shop concludes it needs "a bigger pump" when what it needs is a different kind of pump.
This note sets out how to size a hold-down system properly, why flow matters more than ultimate vacuum on porous material, and which Dr.Vakuum machines suit the duty.
1. What actually holds the workpiece down
The clamping force is the pressure differential across the workpiece acting over the sealed area:
F = Δp × A
With Δp in pascals and A in square metres, F comes out in newtons. A worked case: a 500 × 500 mm panel is 0.25 m². At a differential of 250 mbar (25,000 Pa):
F = 25,000 × 0.25 = 6,250 N ≈ 637 kgf
That number reassures people, and it is the wrong number to design on. Nothing pushes the panel down into the bed during cutting — the cutter pushes it sideways. What resists that is friction:
F_friction = μ × F
For wood on a phenolic or MDF spoilboard, μ is around 0.4. So the 6,250 N of clamping force yields roughly 2,500 N of usable resistance to sliding — and only if the whole 0.25 m² is actually sealed. Against typical radial cutting forces in the tens of newtons, that is a wide margin. The margin collapses, however, as soon as the seal does.
2. Why flow beats ultimate vacuum
A hold-down table is a deliberate, continuous leak. MDF is porous, the spoilboard is porous by design, the gasket is imperfect, and any part of the grid not covered by the workpiece is open to atmosphere. The system never reaches equilibrium — the pump runs against a permanent inflow.
The operating point is therefore set by where the leak curve crosses the pump's pressure–flow curve. This is the crux:
A pump with an excellent ultimate vacuum but low displacement will sit at almost zero differential against a real leak. A pump with a modest ultimate vacuum but high displacement will hold a useful differential all day.
Published measurements on a sealed versus a leaking MDF setup make the point concretely: the same table that reached 285 mbar on a perfectly sealed panel managed only 150 mbar once the board leaked at around 90 m³/h — losing nearly half the available clamping force to leakage alone.
This is why the working band for CNC hold-down is 150–300 mbar differential, i.e. 700–850 mbar absolute. That is nowhere near deep vacuum, and it is precisely why side channel blowers and dry claw pumps own this application while rotary vane pumps — superb at ultimate pressure, modest at displacement — disappoint on it.
3. Sizing by leakage, not by area
Size the machine on the flow the table leaks, not on the vacuum you would like to see on the gauge. Sum three contributions:
- Through the workpiece. Solid hardwood is nearly gas-tight; MDF and particleboard are not. This dominates on porous stock.
- Through the exposed grid. Any pod or grid area not covered by the panel. Blank off unused zones — this is usually the single biggest and cheapest win.
- Through the spoilboard and gasketing. A through-drilled spoilboard is an intentional distributed leak.
As a starting point from field practice:
| Table size | Typical requirement |
|---|---|
| up to 600 × 400 mm | 100–200 m³/h |
| up to 1,000 × 600 mm | 200–300 m³/h |
| larger beds, porous stock | 300–500 m³/h and up |
Then confirm against the machine's curve at the working pressure, not at its free-air rating. A blower quoting 300 m³/h open to atmosphere may deliver appreciably less at 250 mbar, and the figure at duty is the one that holds your panel.
4. Pump-down time, where it matters
For a nested-part job the table pulls down once and stays down, so evacuation time is minor. Where parts change every few seconds it becomes the cycle-time constraint. The standard relation is:
t = (V / S) × ln(p₀ / p₁)
with V the volume to evacuate, S the pumping speed, p₀ the starting pressure and p₁ the target. Two corrections matter in practice:
- The ultimate pressure floor. The naive form implies you reach any pressure given time. You do not. Use t = (V/S) · ln[(p₀ − p_ult)/(p₁ − p_ult)], which correctly goes to infinity as p₁ approaches the machine's ultimate.
- Conductance. The pump's rated speed is not what arrives at the table. 1/S_eff = 1/S + 1/C, where C is the conductance of hose and fittings. Long or narrow hose is a series resistance, and on a short-cycle machine it is often the real bottleneck. Shorten and widen the run before buying a larger pump.
5. Dry, and why it matters on wood
An oil-sealed pump discharges a fine oil mist. On porous stock — MDF, particleboard, veneer, unfinished hardwood — that mist migrates into the surface and shows up later as finish defects: fisheyes in lacquer, glue-line failures, blotching under stain. The part is usually already machined by the time the defect appears, so the scrap is at its most expensive.
Dry-running machines — side channel blowers and claw pumps — have no oil in the working chamber, so the failure mode does not exist. They also remove the oil-change interval and the waste-oil disposal that comes with it.
Recommended Dr.Vakuum machines
Single-stage side channel blowers (1SC Series) are the default choice for hold-down: dry, continuous-duty, and shaped for exactly this high-flow / moderate-vacuum duty.
| Model | Flow at 50 Hz | Suits |
|---|---|---|
| 1SC329 | 2.4 m³/min (144 m³/h) | Benchtop and compact routers |
| 1SC429 | 3.6 m³/min (216 m³/h) | Single-table 1,000 × 600 mm |
| 1SC529 | 5.2 m³/min (312 m³/h) | Full-sheet beds, moderate porosity |
| 1SC729 | 9.2 m³/min (552 m³/h) | Full-sheet beds on MDF |
| 1SC929 | 18.9 m³/min (1,134 m³/h) | Multi-zone tables, nested production |
Dry claw pumps (CL Series) suit shops that need a deeper differential than a side channel blower will hold — thicker gaskets, pod fixtures, or very leaky stock — while staying oil-free.
For heavily porous material or several tables on one header, oversize deliberately. A hold-down system that is marginal when new becomes inadequate as the spoilboard wears and the gaskets age.
Sizing help. Send us your table dimensions, the material, and whether the bed is gridded or pod-based, and our engineers will size the machine against its actual curve at duty. Talk to an engineer.
See also: the same leak-governed physics on robot grippers and lifters in Vacuum pick-and-place, lifting and robotic handling, and the membrane presses and veneer tables of the panel shop in Plywood, veneer and laminate pressing.