Sizing dilute-phase pneumatic conveying
Dilute-phase pneumatic conveying moves powder or granulate by entraining it in a fast-moving air stream. It is mechanically simple — a blower, a pipe, a feeder and a filter receiver — and that simplicity hides the one thing that governs whether the line works: air velocity is not constant along the pipe, and the point where it is lowest is the point where it must not fail.
This note covers how conveying velocity is set, why the blower must be sized at inlet conditions rather than line conditions, and the failure modes that follow from getting either wrong.
1. Solids loading ratio sets the regime
The solids loading ratio (or phase density) is the mass of material carried per unit mass of air:
μ = ṁ_solids / ṁ_air
| Regime | μ (kg solids / kg air) |
|---|---|
| Dilute phase | 5–15 |
| Intermediate | 10–30 |
| Dense phase | > 30 |
The bands overlap deliberately: two materials at the same μ can behave quite differently depending on how well they retain air. One practical limit is worth stating plainly — over longer distances the workable dilute-phase μ falls to around 10, because pushing a higher loading over distance needs pressure a blower cannot supply.
Blower-driven dilute phase generally operates below 1,000 mbar (under 1 bar g). Dense phase runs 1,000–6,000 mbar and is compressor territory.
2. Minimum conveying velocity
Below a certain air velocity, particles drop out of suspension and settle on the bottom of a horizontal pipe. That threshold is the saltation velocity; the vertical equivalent, where the column collapses, is called choking.
Published minimum conveying velocities, by material class:
| Material | Minimum conveying velocity |
|---|---|
| Fine powders — cement, flour, fly ash | 10–12 m/s |
| Coarse granular — sand, granulated sugar, alumina | 13–16 m/s |
| Plastic pellets | ~20 m/s, and below 25 m/s to avoid angel hair |
| Dense phase, air-retentive powders | as low as 3 m/s |
The standard estimator for saltation velocity is the Rizk correlation, which relates the loading ratio to a Froude number with exponents that depend on particle size:
μ = (1 / 10^a) · [ U_salt / √(g·D) ]^b where a = 1100d + 2.5, b = 1440d + 1.96
with d the particle diameter and D the pipe bore, both in metres. That unit note matters: the same correlation is often written as a = 1.1d + 2.5 with d in millimetres. Mixing the two forms is a factor-of-1000 error and it is a common one.
Rizk carries roughly ±54% average error and suits fine powders below 200 µm best. Treat it as a starting estimate, not a design value. Standard practice is to set the pickup velocity 20–30% above the calculated saltation velocity, to absorb feed surges and blower tolerance.
3. Pressure drop, and an honest warning
Total line pressure drop is additive:
Δp_total = Δp_horizontal + Δp_vertical + Δp_bends + Δp_acceleration + Δp_filter
- Horizontal: gas-to-pipe friction + solids-to-pipe friction + acceleration
- Vertical: the same, plus the static head of the solids column
- Bends: commonly estimated as 7.5 m of equivalent vertical pipe per 90° elbow, plus the re-acceleration of material downstream of each bend
- Solids friction factor: λ_s = 0.001–0.010, material dependent
The air-only term is Darcy–Weisbach:
Δp_air = λ · (L/D) · (ρ·U²/2)
The warning is as important as the formulas: published dilute-phase pressure-drop models are not precise, and should not be used for detail design. They size a first pass. A line carrying an unfamiliar material should be confirmed against test-loop data or vendor sizing, not against an equation.
4. The expansion problem
This is the part most often missed, and it is the reason lines fail.
Air is compressible. As pressure falls along the pipe the air expands, and since Q = V·A, velocity rises. In a real measured system, velocity ran 29 m/s at pickup and 41 m/s at discharge — a 1.4× swing along one line.
Two consequences follow:
- Design at the pickup point. The lowest velocity is at the start of the line. If that point sits below saltation, the line plugs regardless of how fast the air is moving at the far end.
- Then check the discharge end. If expansion pushes the exit velocity past the attrition threshold, the fix is a stepped-bore pipeline — increasing the pipe diameter in stages down the run — not a slower blower, which would starve the pickup end.
For the same reason, dilute-phase conveying is generally unsuitable beyond about 1,000 m.
5. Sizing the blower at inlet conditions
A blower is rated at its suction conditions, and a vacuum conveying line does not operate there. The correction is large enough to sink a project.
A worked case: a line requiring 350 m³/h at the pickup point, running at 300 mbar vacuum, needs 497 m³/h at the blower suction — a factor of 1.42. An engineer who reads 350 m³/h off the line calculation and orders a 350 m³/h blower has under-sized by 30%, and the line will never reach pickup velocity.
Size against the worst case, not steady state:
- Restart against a loaded line. A line that stops full must break a settled bed loose before flow re-establishes. Steady-state Δp badly understates this.
- A dirty filter, not a clean one. Filter Δp typically runs 12–50 mbar and rises through the cleaning cycle. A system commissioned against a clean filter has no margin the first time the bags load.
6. Failure modes
Too slow — saltation and plugging. Material settles, the line blocks, and clearing it is a manual job.
Too fast — attrition and wear. Particles strike the wall harder; product degrades into fines and elbows erode. In a documented case, running at 29–41 m/s and μ = 3.4 was breaking product; the fix was slowing to 19.9 m/s pickup at μ = 5 — more material per unit air, not less.
Angel hair and streamers, on plastics. Pellets slide against the wall, friction melts a film, and it accumulates until it peels away. Bends are worst because centrifugal force is highest there. The mitigation is counter-intuitive — rougher pipe and tighter bend radii — and it directly opposes what reduces fines, which wants smooth pipe and long-radius bends. You cannot optimise both. Choose the defect that costs you more.
A blinded filter starves the blower. An undersized filter receiver raises differential pressure, blinds the bags, and drops line velocity below saltation. The line then plugs — and the cause is in the filter, not the pipe. Keep pulse-jet air-to-cloth ratio in the 0.01–0.075 m/s band.
Heat. A roots blower has no internal compression, so the isentropic temperature rise is a floor, not a prediction. Roots machines are held to about a 2:1 compression ratio for this reason. A relief valve venting to atmosphere is not optional on a positive-displacement blower: dead-head one and it will keep displacing air until something fails.
7. Why a blower and not a compressor
Conveying wants high volume at a low pressure ratio, usually under 2:1. Reciprocating compressors are built for the opposite — low flow, high ratio — and they deliver pulsating flow that destabilises the suspension around the saltation floor. Most are oil-lubricated, which contaminates product.
Within the blower family:
- Side channel blowers are non-positive-displacement. Slip past the running clearance rises steeply with differential pressure, so the curve rolls off: dead-head one and it simply stops delivering flow rather than building pressure without limit. That inherent self-limiting is why they suit dilute phase, and also why they top out near 1,000 mbar.
- Roots blowers have an almost vertical curve — flow stays nearly constant as pressure rises. That is what suits them to denser loadings, and exactly why they need relief protection.
Both run oil-free, which in food, pharmaceutical and plastics conveying is a product-contamination question rather than a preference.
Recommended Dr.Vakuum machines
Single-stage side channel blowers (1SC Series) — dilute phase, vacuum or pressure conveying.
| Model | Flow at 50 Hz | Differential |
|---|---|---|
| 1SC429 | 3.6 m³/min (216 m³/h) | 210 / 220 mbar |
| 1SC629 | 5.2 m³/min (312 m³/h) | 255 / 280 mbar |
| 1SC729 | 9.2 m³/min (552 m³/h) | 270 / 300 mbar |
| 1SC929 | 18.9 m³/min (1,134 m³/h) | 305 / 295 mbar |
| 1SC939 | 18.9 m³/min (1,134 m³/h) | 350 / 440 mbar |
Two-stage side channel blowers (2SC Series) — where the line needs more differential than a single stage will hold. A second stage buys pressure and costs flow, so choose it for pressure, not capacity.
| Model | Flow at 50 Hz | Differential |
|---|---|---|
| 2SC6355 | 5.2 m³/min (312 m³/h) | 410 / 515 mbar |
| 2SC8320 | 9.6 m³/min (576 m³/h) | 450 / 700 mbar |
Roots blowers (RB / RBV Series) — higher loadings and longer runs, to 8,000 mmAq pressure or −5,000 mmAq vacuum.
Sizing help. Send us the material, throughput, line length and layout, the bends, and the vertical rise, and our engineers will work the pickup velocity and the inlet-condition correction through with you. Talk to an engineer.
See also: the other regime — multiple pick-up points, hygienic and dusty materials, and the −300 to −500 mbar window — in Vacuum (suction) conveying of rice, sugar and granules.