Dr.Vakuum
All applications

Dry, oil-sealed or liquid ring: choosing a vacuum pump by what is in the gas

7 min read

Once a duty has been placed by pressure and flow — see How to size a vacuum pump — there are usually two or three technologies that could do it. In the 10–100 mbar band, for instance, a liquid ring pump, an oil-sealed vane pump and a dry screw pump all have the speed. What is in the gas chooses between them, and getting it wrong is the commonest cause of a pump that fails in months rather than years.

1. The five things that kill pumps

Every vacuum pump handles clean dry air indefinitely. The problems are the other components of the inlet stream.

Water vapour. Compressed from process pressure to atmosphere inside the pump, vapour condenses unless the pump is hot enough or ballasted enough. In an oil-sealed pump it emulsifies the oil; in a dry pump it corrodes and, in cold spots, collects. A liquid ring pump does not care — water is its working fluid.

Solvents and organic vapours. Behave like water with an extra effect: they dissolve into oil (raising its vapour pressure and ruining the ultimate), attack elastomers, and in a dry pump can polymerise on hot rotors. Flammability adds a safety dimension.

Dust and particles. Abrade vanes and seals, pack into clearances, and in an oil-sealed pump form a grinding paste. Filterable to a point; beyond it the pump must be one that passes solids.

Oxygen enrichment. Above 21–25 % O₂, mineral oil in a hot oil-sealed pump is a fire risk; PFPE oil or a dry pump is required. Common in medical oxygen concentrators, ozone and some chemical duties.

Corrosives. Acid gases, chlorine, HCl from PVC processing, ammonia. Material selection and the condensate chemistry decide everything.

Why does the same gas hurt one pump and not another?

Because the pumps compress the gas differently. An oil-sealed vane pump compresses in a thin oil film that touches every molecule — anything soluble or condensable ends up in the oil, and the oil is also the seal, so contaminated oil means a failing pump. A dry screw or claw pump compresses with running clearances and no sealing fluid, so the gas touches only hot metal: condensables that stay vapour pass through, and particles that fit through the clearances pass too. A liquid ring pump compresses with water, which absorbs the gas's heat and condenses its vapour load into a liquid it then discharges — the gas is effectively washed. Each architecture is strong where the others are weak, and the gas composition tells you which strength you need.

2. The technologies, honestly

Oil-sealed vane (V, DV) Dry vane (DRV, DRD, DRK) Dry claw (CL) Dry screw (DSI, DSC) Liquid ring (LM, LT, LS)
Ultimate 0.5 / 5 × 10⁻³ mbar 90 mbar 150 (50) mbar 0.05 mbar 33 mbar
Water vapour Tolerated with gas ballast, limited kg/h Poor — condensation in chamber Good — passes through, drain Good — runs hot, passes through Excellent
Solvents Poor to fair (oil contamination) Poor Fair (hot, passes) Good (hot, inert) Good if seal liquid compatible
Dust Poor (grinding paste) Poor (vane wear) Fair with filter Good with filter Good (washed)
Oxygen-rich PFPE oil only Fair Good Good Excellent
Corrosives Poor Poor Material-dependent Good with coatings Excellent with SS
Energy per m³/h Low Low Low Medium High (seal water + motor)
Noise Low Medium Medium Medium Low
Service Oil change 500–2,000 h Vanes 5–10 kh Annual check Annual check Seal water quality
Exhaust Oil mist (separator) Dry Dry, hot Dry, hot Wet, cool

3. Three questions to a series

Question 1 — Is there liquid, or vapour that will condense?

If the answer is yes in quantity (more than a few kg/h of water, any free liquid), the stream wants a liquid ring pump or a dry screw. Liquid ring is the economical choice from 33 mbar upward when cooling water is available; the LM Series for 30–450 m³/h, the LT two-stage where the pressure is 40–80 mbar, the LS for large flows. Dry screw (DSI Series) is the choice when the vapour is a solvent to be recovered, when water is scarce or must not be discharged, or when the pressure is below 30 mbar. If the answer is "a little vapour", an oil-sealed vane pump with gas ballast handles it — the V140 tolerates 2 kg/h, the V630 17 kg/h — and a knock-out pot or condenser upstream handles more.

Question 2 — Is the process open to the product?

Food contact, pharmaceutical product, electronics assembly, medical: anywhere oil mist in the exhaust or back-streaming into the chamber is unacceptable. Dry is the answer, and the pressure chooses which dry: DRV dry vane down to 90 mbar, CL claw to 150 (CL300: 50) mbar, DSI screw to 0.05 mbar. If the process is closed and the pump never shares an atmosphere with the product — a vessel pump, a backing pump — oil-sealed is fine and cheaper.

Question 3 — Is there dust, and can it be filtered?

Fine dust that a 5 µm inlet filter catches is a filter problem, and any pump will do behind a correctly sized filter changed by differential pressure. Dust that is continuous and heavy (powder drying, pneumatic conveying receivers, clay degassing) or sticky (sugar, resins) is a pump problem: a liquid ring washes it out; a dry screw with a cyclone passes most of it; an oil-sealed vane pump should not be used. A Roots vacuum blower (RBV) handles the shallow-vacuum, high-flow dust duties (conveying, cleaning) with wide clearances.

4. Specific streams

Steam-heavy, hot (sterilisers, retorts, cook-chill). Liquid ring, or a condenser ahead of anything else. Oil-sealed pumps fail on the water load; dry claw tolerates it if kept hot.

Solvent recovery (acetone, ethanol, toluene, THF). Dry screw with a downstream condenser, so the solvent arrives at the condenser hot and undiluted — see Solvent recovery in a fine chemical plant. Liquid ring with the solvent itself as the ring liquid is the classic alternative where the solvent is cheap and water-immiscible.

Chlorinated and acid gases (PVC, pickling, electroplating degassing). Liquid ring in stainless or with a caustic ring liquid that neutralises as it pumps; or dry screw with coated rotors and nitrogen purge. Never an oil-sealed pump.

Oxygen (concentrators, PSA, ozone). Dry claw or dry vane; or oil-sealed with PFPE oil, which costs ten times mineral oil and is worth it only when the ultimate is needed.

Hydrocarbons and oil mist (degassing lubricants, transformer oil, frying). Oil-sealed vane pumps cope if the oil is changed frequently; dry screw is better; liquid ring makes an emulsion that must be separated.

Flammable vapours (ATEX). Dry screw with gas-tight shaft seals and nitrogen purge, or liquid ring, with the whole system — not just the pump — assessed. The ignition risk in an oil-sealed pump is the hot oil and the vane friction.

Abrasive dust at shallow vacuum (conveying, ceramics). Roots vacuum blower with a cyclone and filter receiver; the clearances are millimetres, not microns.

5. Protecting whichever pump you choose

The gas question is often answered not by changing the pump but by changing what reaches it — the subject of Inlet filtration, condensers and knock-out pots. In outline:

  • Knock-out pot for liquid slugs and foam — a simple vessel with a level switch that stops the pump.
  • Condenser (water or chilled) for vapour — removes 80–95 % of the load before the pump and often lets a pump two sizes smaller do the job.
  • Inlet filter for dust, rated for the particle size, changed by differential pressure.
  • Gas ballast on oil-sealed pumps, open whenever vapour is present.
  • Purge gas (nitrogen) through dry pump seals and the exhaust to dilute condensables below their dew point.

Recommended Dr.Vakuum machines by gas

Gas character First choice Alternative
Clean dry air, deep vacuum V / DV oil-sealed vane DSI dry screw
Clean dry air, oil-free required DRV dry vane (≥ 90 mbar) CL claw
Saturated / wet / steam LM / LT liquid ring V with condenser and ballast
Solvent vapour, to be recovered DSI + condenser LT with solvent ring
Dust, continuous LM liquid ring DSI + cyclone; RBV at shallow vacuum
Oxygen-enriched CL / DRV dry V with PFPE oil
Corrosive Liquid ring, stainless DSI with coating and purge
Food / pharma contact DRV, CL, DSI dry —

Example models: V140, DV90, DRV40, CL150, DSI300, LM200-065, LT230-160V, RBV100.

Tell us what is in the gas. The composition, temperature and any liquid carry-over, plus the pressure and flow, and we will say which technology survives it and what to put in front of the pump. Talk to an engineer.